Thursday, August 8, 2013

COMMENTARY FOR LILY



Your overall policy is to develop something called media literacy which involves educating young people. In your other essay, the first paragraph, you do talk about the problem and that it can be solved. However, I might would take out the parts about the counterargument or state it a different way. Someone might actually think it is impossible to do since you yourself think there are holes in it. Maybe you can talk about it being a class kids can take in school? The first amendment is a barrier so maybe you could say that media literacy wouldn’t go against it to elaborate a little more? In the second paragraph where you say “possibly” and then continue talking about other classes, I think would benefit from a transition. At the end of that paragraph I thought you did a really good job at transitioning to the next paragraph though! 

Typically, the media would not care who watches. I think they also believe that their audience does not include children. I never watched the news when I was younger. The paragraph at the end of page two that goes into page three might need a little more elaboration. The last few sentences also do not make much sense. You could benefit from rereading this paragraph and trying to explain and reword the information a little better. 

I think a skeptic would doubt the policy because of the way you say it has holes. I agree that teaching awareness is hard to do and hard to force on to people, but maybe you could say that that does not matter. We should at least try to get children to be aware so maybe you could put those thoughts in. A skeptic could point out that negative consequences could be how much it would cost to get the public to have this knowledge or the amount of time. The way you would gain this information about the media is to start children off at a young age which would make people think: well what about the generation that is already grown up? They might would also bring up the fact that the violence from the stories could end up on the internet. That being said, I do not think that a counterproposal is available. Media violence is obviously going to be around so just teaching people to be more aware is probably the only way to solve the problem.